Taking The Canon 24-105mm F2.8L For A Spin: A Real World Test

Quick take: Canon markets the RF 24-105mm F2.8L as a video lens, but it's an outstanding photo lens too. It covers the 24-70 and overlaps the 70-200 at F2.8, so you can one-lens almost any event. Its weight and $3,000 price line up with what you'd pay for that range in the Trinity lenses. For working event pros, it's a no-brainer. For vacations, it's a lot to carry.

A Video Lens? Sort Of.

Canon pitches the RF 24-105mm F2.8L IS USM Z as video-first. It has a de-clicked aperture ring labeled "Iris," not aperture, and you can buy an optional power zoom attachment. I haven't, and I'm curious how many people do. The iris ring only works in video mode right now, and since it's de-clicked I wouldn't use it for photos anyway. It's too easy to bump.

Oddly for a "video lens," it isn't parfocal. That's not a deal breaker for me, since I use autofocus constantly for photo and video. So for this video I tested it as if I were a photographer who never shoots video. My verdict: it's much better than anyone gives it credit for.

I've had it for about three months, and it hasn't left my Canon R5 C.

One Lens for Almost Any Event

The Trinity lenses are the 15-35mm (16-35 on some systems), 24-70mm and 70-200mm, all at F2.8. The 15-35 and 24-70 overlap from 24 to 35mm. Until now, the 24-70 and 70-200 didn't overlap at all. This lens closes that gap.

That matters most at live events. Covering strongman competitions, you're often planted in one spot so you don't block the TV or livestream cameras. With a 24-70, athletes at the far end looked like phone footage. With a 70-200, they'd get too close at the finish. I ended up carrying a second body with the other lens and constantly swapping. You can't reshoot a live event, and now one lens covers the whole range at F2.8.

Cropping on 45 Megapixels

Paired with the R5 C's 45MP sensor, the overlap with the 70-200 goes even further. In my shoot with Victoria, I punched in 200 to 400 percent on many shots and changed the composition completely. The lens is sharp wide open, so the only people who'll know you cropped are you and maybe your printer.

At events, you sometimes have seconds to decide whether to grab the other body and wait for it to wake up, or just take the shot and crop later. With this lens and 45 megapixels, take the shot.

Bonus for Video Shooters

If you offer video as a second service, the R5 C's crop modes add even more range. Super 35 mode (1.6x crop) gets you roughly 38-170mm equivalent with a full 4K readout. Super 16 gets you around 70-300mm with a 3K readout. Keep in mind it's a crop, not true telephoto compression.

The Weight Criticism Doesn't Hold Up

The main knock on this lens is that it's big and heavy. But there's no other 24-105mm F2.8 on the market from any brand, and the math works out.

  • The RF 24-70mm F2.8 weighs 31.8 oz. The RF 70-200mm F2.8 weighs 37.8 oz.

  • The extra 70-105mm range is 35mm out of the 70-200's 130mm span, about 26.9%. That share of the 70-200's weight is about 10.2 oz.

  • The 24-70 plus that slice comes to about 42 oz. The 24-105 weighs 46.9 oz.

So about 5 extra ounces gets you a de-clicked iris, power zoom support and overlap with the 70-200. It's also lighter and slimmer than the old EF 70-200, which is a size most of us already know.

The Price Makes Sense Too

At $3,000 it isn't cheap. The same math: the 24-70mm F2.8 is $2,400 and the 70-200mm F2.8 is $2,800 at full price. That 26.9% slice of the 70-200 is about $753. Add it to the 24-70 and you get about $3,153. So you're paying about the same, or slightly less, per millimeter of range as the rest of the Trinity, with extra features thrown in.

It's not scientific, but that's how I justified buying this instead of replacing my stolen 24-70. Thanks to Carlos for lending me his for this video.

The Shoot

The photos are from my first shoot in New Jersey since moving back, with Victoria, with hair by my friend Maica, who you may know from my G1X Mark III video. I grew up in Jersey, but I wasn't into cameras before I left, so it's fun seeing the state through a different lens. I wished I'd had a circular polarizer for a couple of shots, and a few frames were cropped aggressively, but with 45 megapixels you'd never know.

Final Thoughts

If you're a working professional covering any kind of event and you don't already own a 24-70, this is the lens to get. It solves real problems in a live environment, and that's invaluable. If you just want something to travel with, its size and weight will feel like a lot. Older pro bodies like the original Canon 5D are a better buy for most non-professionals, and I'll be making a video about that soon.

Keep Reading

Gear in This Video

Gear in this video

My Canon gear

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Buying through these links costs you nothing extra and helps support the channel.

Previous
Previous

Upgrade Your Phone Videos: Five Essentials For Pro Results

Next
Next

My Favorite Fujifilm Portrait Combo